View Single Post
  #23   Report Post  
Old December 3rd 03, 04:52 PM posted to uk.transport.london
Smith F Smith F is offline
external usenet poster
 
First recorded activity at LondonBanter: Dec 2003
Posts: 1
Default Legal challenges and congestion charging for 30 second journey leaving zone?

Personally I would drive further into the zone and make a day of it. You
have paid for a days worth after all. Its surprising how much congestion you
could make in a single car especially if you treat it as a day out. Take
some sandwiches and fizzy drink!

Next time, get your £5 worth. And if WE are really lucky perhaps you can
chalk up mad Ken as road kill!

(I'm not anti congestion charge, with a little more thought, and perhaps a
sliding scale over a wider area it will be good, but mad Ken is not the man
to direct it, we need someone who is actually living on the same planet as
the rest of us )


I.



"Nick" wrote in message
om...
In principle I've been agreeing with the congestion charge, but that
was until I was caught in this trap. On an evening and outside zone
hours I would like to drive to my g/f's flat that's inside the zone by
about 100 yards drive. In the morning I would leave the private car
park, enter the zone to drive 30 seconds or even less on a deserted
side street to reach the zone exit and enter a dual lane main road
with no problems and not affecting the almost non-flow of traffic on
that particular road. Not believing that I'd have to pay 5 pounds for
the privilege of my negligible zone journey to exit the zone I've not
only one fine so far (unjust but I can live with it), but the prospect
of upwards of a thousands pounds or more. This is patently unjust and
I wonder how the scheme handles these cases. Any experiences? At a
pinch perhaps one would be elligible for a residents discount although
for someone technically not a resident, on the face of it probably
not.

From a legal standpoint, is anyone aware of any test cases so far that
challenge the reasonableness of a fixed charge? Charging the same of
someone making essentially a non journey and someone spending all day
driving in the zone, adding to not only congestion of traffic but also
that of street goers lungs from polution seems contestable and
unreasonable on the basis of any tests of reasonableness.

Perhaps the charging system should only charge if a driver is within
the zone for more than a certain period of time, and if entry to the
zone was not on file when recording a zone exit before a certain time
in the morning then no fee should be charged. This would probably not
reduce revenue much and be considerably more reasonable.

n.