Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
![]() |
|
London Transport (uk.transport.london) Discussion of all forms of transport in London. |
Reply |
|
|
LinkBack | Thread Tools | Display Modes |
|
#1
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
Do London buses carry cameras that show a
view of the road forward or back from the bus? Are the recordings retained and available to police, as possible evidence of offences by other road users, where the bus isn't itself involved? |
#2
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
"Arthur Lemming" wrote in message
... Do London buses carry cameras that show a view of the road forward or back from the bus? Are the recordings retained and available to police, as possible evidence of offences by other road users, where the bus isn't itself involved? Re your first question - generally yes and many also have cameras showing views to the side. No idea about the other one. |
#3
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
In message , at 12:50:04 on Tue, 8 Oct
2013, August West remarked: But there's no legal requirement for TfL (or other CCTV operators) to release recordings to third parties Other than a court order. But they would have a good excuse for voluntarily releasing them under DPA s29. they are not actually recorded in the images. Although I imagine they cooperate with the police, who could obtain warrants for the material, anyway. Warrants under which statute? -- Roland Perry |
#4
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
Warren is under the Roosevelt statue.
|
#5
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
In message , at 16:53:44 on Tue, 8 Oct
2013, August West remarked: they are not actually recorded in the images. Although I imagine they cooperate with the police, who could obtain warrants for the material, anyway. Warrants under which statute? It would be at Common Law in Scotland, not statute; I have no idea about England (I suppose I should have qualifed my statement). But I would be very surprised if there was no such power. The offences concerned are unlikely to justify a search warrant of the perpetrator's home, let alone a search warrant for a bus (assuming you could identify the exact bus) that happened to be somewhere near where they might have committed the offence. -- Roland Perry |
#6
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
In message , at 01:36:13 on
Wed, 9 Oct 2013, Paul Corfield remarked: As I suspect the original question might relate to a road traffic accident, possibly involving a cyclist, then I could foresee circumstances where a search of a garage connected to a home and gathering of photographic / video evidence from vehicles, CCTV cameras or individuals might be made. Photographic evidence might be collected from a bus if it's still there when the police arrive after an accident. It'd have to be a pretty odd accident for the houses of the persons involved to be searched. -- Roland Perry |
#7
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
In message , at 09:56:50 on
Wed, 9 Oct 2013, Paul Corfield remarked: As I suspect the original question might relate to a road traffic accident, possibly involving a cyclist, then I could foresee circumstances where a search of a garage connected to a home and gathering of photographic / video evidence from vehicles, CCTV cameras or individuals might be made. Photographic evidence might be collected from a bus if it's still there when the police arrive after an accident. It'd have to be a pretty odd accident for the houses of the persons involved to be searched. Hit and run and somebody tries to hide their car at / near their home? That's the sort of "odd accident" I had in mind. To save typing I didn't go on to describe them, but another would be a deliberate attempt to injure someone. Of course, doing that sort of thing in a car registered to your home address is a bit of an own-goal. Having been the victim of such an accident I know the police went to a suspect's home to try to find the vehicle involved in the accident. I agree it wouldn't be an every day event but it wouldn't be impossible either. -- Roland Perry |
#8
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]() "Paul Corfield" wrote in message ... On Tue, 8 Oct 2013 21:19:47 +0100, Roland Perry wrote: In message , at 16:53:44 on Tue, 8 Oct 2013, August West remarked: they are not actually recorded in the images. Although I imagine they cooperate with the police, who could obtain warrants for the material, anyway. Warrants under which statute? It would be at Common Law in Scotland, not statute; I have no idea about England (I suppose I should have qualifed my statement). But I would be very surprised if there was no such power. The offences concerned are unlikely to justify a search warrant of the perpetrator's home, let alone a search warrant for a bus (assuming you could identify the exact bus) that happened to be somewhere near where they might have committed the offence. As I suspect the original question might relate to a road traffic accident, possibly involving a cyclist, then I could foresee circumstances where a search of a garage connected to a home and gathering of photographic / video evidence from vehicles, CCTV cameras or individuals might be made. Whether that would involve warrants I could not say - outside my knowledge. My question was triggered by reading of some pedestrians using a light-controlled pedestrian crossing. A bus had already stopped at red. The road itself is only wide enough for one motor vehicle in each direction. The pedestrians, crossing the road, walked out of the cover of the bus without checking further, and reportedly just missed getting knocked down by a car that was overtaking the bus, but were I believe unharmed. Given the possible existence of video recordings of the incident, I think the only question really is whether the police could or would take any significant action if the incident was reported. |
#9
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
In message , at 10:23:34 on Wed, 9 Oct
2013, Arthur Lemming remarked: My question was triggered by reading of some pedestrians using a light-controlled pedestrian crossing. A bus had already stopped at red. The road itself is only wide enough for one motor vehicle in each direction. The pedestrians, crossing the road, walked out of the cover of the bus without checking further, and reportedly just missed getting knocked down by a car that was overtaking the bus, but were I believe unharmed. Given the possible existence of video recordings of the incident, I think the only question really is whether the police could or would take any significant action if the incident was reported. Given that no-one was injured, and it wasn't witnessed first hand by the police, and presumably wasn't reported as soon as it had happened, then I don't hold out much hope for them being very interested. If they were interested, they could identify the specific bus, and the recording still existed, I would expect that the bus company would respond to a relevant Data Protection s29 notice (but if they wanted as a matter of public policy to avoid becoming a surrogate traffic-offence camera operator rather than a bus company they might well decide to generically expire the cctv recordings sooner than the average s29 can be actioned). Obviously, there's also the possibility of a court order, but whether a court would regard this scenario as a good use of their time is another matter. -- Roland Perry |
#10
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
"Paul Corfield" wrote in message
... On Tue, 8 Oct 2013 21:19:47 +0100, Roland Perry wrote: In message , at 16:53:44 on Tue, 8 Oct 2013, August West remarked: they are not actually recorded in the images. Although I imagine they cooperate with the police, who could obtain warrants for the material, anyway. Warrants under which statute? It would be at Common Law in Scotland, not statute; I have no idea about England (I suppose I should have qualifed my statement). But I would be very surprised if there was no such power. The offences concerned are unlikely to justify a search warrant of the perpetrator's home, let alone a search warrant for a bus (assuming you could identify the exact bus) that happened to be somewhere near where they might have committed the offence. As I suspect the original question might relate to a road traffic accident, possibly involving a cyclist, then I could foresee circumstances where a search of a garage connected to a home and gathering of photographic / video evidence from vehicles, CCTV cameras or individuals might be made. Whether that would involve warrants I could not say - outside my knowledge. My question was triggered by reading of some pedestrians using a light-controlled pedestrian crossing. A bus had already stopped at red. The road itself is only wide enough for one motor vehicle in each direction. The pedestrians, crossing the road, walked out of the cover of the bus without checking further and reportedly just missed getting knocked down by a car that was overtaking the bus, but were I believe unharmed. Given the possible existence of video recordings of the incident, I think the only question really is whether the police could or would take any significant action if the incident was reported. The time it occurred would be knowable. The people had just got off a train. I don't know if they noted the bus route, but there wouldn't be more than three possibilities. |
Reply |
|
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
![]() |
||||
Thread | Forum | |||
CCTV Recordings | London Transport | |||
TfL CCTV going digital | London Transport | |||
TfL CCTV going digital | London Transport | |||
TfL CCTV going digital | London Transport | |||
CCTV | London Transport |