London Banter

London Banter (https://www.londonbanter.co.uk/forum.php)
-   London Transport (https://www.londonbanter.co.uk/london-transport/)
-   -   Hello from New York (https://www.londonbanter.co.uk/london-transport/758-hello-new-york.html)

Knotso September 26th 03 05:02 AM

Hello from New York
 
Hi all and have patience with a newcomer.

I'm visiting London in a month -- for the first time -- and staying with a
friend who lives in Greenwich. Pondering the tube map from Heathrow, it appears
to be something like a 2-hour ride from the airport, to Green Park, to the
Jubilee line to South Greenwich. But then, I have no benchmark to judge how
long a ride it really is. Can anyone provide an estimate?

Being conditioned by New York subway maps, I have to admit the London schematic
map drives me nuts. I can't get a true sense of direction of how close a
station is to a landmark. Which leads to my next question ... do any geographic
maps of the tube exist? Where are they?

Well, it should be an eye-opener riding the London tube for the first time
after 3 years of living with New York subways. Anyone with experience commuting
on both transit systems who can venture opinions about the differences between
the two cities?

I've probably bothered you enough, but I welcome your opinions.

J


Paul Terry September 26th 03 07:23 AM

Hello from New York
 
In message , Knotso
writes

I'm visiting London in a month -- for the first time -- and staying with a
friend who lives in Greenwich. Pondering the tube map from Heathrow, it appears
to be something like a 2-hour ride from the airport, to Green Park, to the
Jubilee line to South Greenwich. But then, I have no benchmark to judge how
long a ride it really is. Can anyone provide an estimate?


45 minutes from Heathrow to Green Park
10 minutes for interchange (see below)
20 minutes from Green Park to North Greenwich
--
75 minutes total

The Transport for London Journey planner gives timings:
http://journeyplanner.tfl.gov.uk/index.htm
But beware that it can give some rather odd routes - you are better
asking here for details!

I seem to remember that the interchange at Green Park involves quite a
long underground walk - if you have heavy luggage it may be better to
change from Piccadilly to District at Hammersmith (simple cross-platform
interchange) and then pick-up the Jubilee line at Westminster (where
there are lifts and escalators).

However, note that the Jubilee doesn't go to "South Greenwich" - was
that a typo, or can you be more specific in where you want to end up?
There may be better alternatives, such as taking the mainline railway
out to Greenwich from central London (SE London is well served by
numerous commuter lines, and a branch of the Docklands Light Railway,
but is poorly served by the underground system.)

Being conditioned by New York subway maps, I have to admit the London schematic
map drives me nuts. I can't get a true sense of direction of how close a
station is to a landmark. Which leads to my next question ... do any geographic
maps of the tube exist? Where are they?


Not easy to find on the WWW, but there is a quite good one at the end of
the following PDF document (820K):

http://www.londontransport.co.uk/tfl.../marketone.pdf

If you take a look at this you will see how the Jubilee line runs well
north of the main part of Greenwich - although North Greenwich station
may well be a good option if you are going to be picked-up by car.

--
Paul Terry

Graham J September 26th 03 07:42 AM

Hello from New York
 
Being conditioned by New York subway maps, I have to admit the London
schematic
map drives me nuts. I can't get a true sense of direction of how close a
station is to a landmark. Which leads to my next question ... do any

geographic
maps of the tube exist? Where are they?


There are some around but I can't say I've ever felt a need for them as the
stations are marked on street and bus maps and sooner or later one of those
will be required unless you are being met, in which case it isn't a problem.

The Jubilee Line goes to North Greenwich which is slightly off the beaten
track a bit. Unless that is where your friend has suggested you go to I
would suggest you ask him/her which station is the most convenient.
'Maritime Greenwich' is served by Greenwich station which is on the DLR and
also an overground line and the latter are often more convenient.

It might, for example, be more convenient to change from the Piccadilly to
the District Line at Hammersmith or Barons Court (you just walk across an
island platform there which is handy with heavy luggage) and then go to
Cannon Street for a direct train to Greenwich.

G.



Cast_Iron September 26th 03 08:32 AM

Hello from New York
 
Knotso wrote:
Hi all and have patience with a newcomer.

I'm visiting London in a month -- for the first time -- and
staying with a friend who lives in Greenwich. Pondering the
tube map from Heathrow, it appears to be something like a
2-hour ride from the airport, to Green Park, to the Jubilee
line to South Greenwich. But then, I have no benchmark to
judge how long a ride it really is. Can anyone provide an
estimate?


Allowing two minutes per station gives a reasonably accurate journey time.



Boltar September 26th 03 09:28 AM

Hello from New York
 
(Knotso) wrote in message ...
I'm visiting London in a month -- for the first time -- and staying with a
friend who lives in Greenwich. Pondering the tube map from Heathrow, it appears
to be something like a 2-hour ride from the airport, to Green Park, to the
Jubilee line to South Greenwich. But then, I have no benchmark to judge how
long a ride it really is. Can anyone provide an estimate?


From the airport to Green Park is about 1 hour , maybe a bit longer. Then from
Green Park to Greenwich is about 15 - 20 minutes depending on the time of
day. This is of curse assuming there isn't the usual balls up on either line.

Well, it should be an eye-opener riding the London tube for the first time
after 3 years of living with New York subways. Anyone with experience commuting
on both transit systems who can venture opinions about the differences between
the two cities?


The MTA in new york can actually manage to run a reasonable service. LU can't.
In london there are forever delays , trains being reversed before they've
got to their destination because the train (ie driver) is running late (wants
to get home for tea), stations being closed because of some lift or escalator
not working, incorrect train arrival indicators and so on. Don't ever rely on
the tube to get you to your destination on time and this especially applies
when you're going to the airport on it.
Sorry , if this sounds negative but I'm a londoner and I've ridden on many
metro systems (including the NYC subway many times) around the world and IMO
the tube is one of the worst run and managed I've ever come across plus its
the most expensive.

B2003

Martin S. September 26th 03 01:34 PM

Hello from New York
 
(Knotso) wrote in message ...
Hi all and have patience with a newcomer.

I'm visiting London in a month -- for the first time -- and staying with a
friend who lives in Greenwich. Pondering the tube map from Heathrow, it appears
to be something like a 2-hour ride from the airport, to Green Park, to the
Jubilee line to South Greenwich. But then, I have no benchmark to judge how
long a ride it really is. Can anyone provide an estimate?

Being conditioned by New York subway maps, I have to admit the London schematic
map drives me nuts. I can't get a true sense of direction of how close a
station is to a landmark. Which leads to my next question ... do any geographic
maps of the tube exist? Where are they?

Well, it should be an eye-opener riding the London tube for the first time
after 3 years of living with New York subways. Anyone with experience commuting
on both transit systems who can venture opinions about the differences between
the two cities?

I've probably bothered you enough, but I welcome your opinions.

J


Look at
www.thetube.com and click on routefinder. It gives a rough
idea of journey times.
Regarding geographic tube maps, the best modern map of the central
area is at wwww.fourthway.co.uk - click on 'The Real Underground', and
have a look through the options in the popup window.

HTH

Roland Perry September 26th 03 06:00 PM

Hello from New York
 
In message , Knotso
writes
who lives in Greenwich. Pondering the tube map from Heathrow, it appears
to be something like a 2-hour ride from the airport, to Green Park, to the
Jubilee line to South Greenwich.


It's "North Greenwich", which is nowhere near what the locals would call
Greenwich. The actual centre of Greenwich is between the Cutty Sark and
Greenwich DLR stations. But don't try changing from the Jubilee to DLR
at Canary Wharf because it's a long way to walk. It would be much better
to get an overground train to Greenwich (probably from Charing Cross,
walk from Embankment tube, having changed at Hammersmith).
--
Roland Perry

kedron September 26th 03 07:41 PM

Hello from New York
 

In
Roland Perry wrote:

It's "North Greenwich", which is nowhere near what the locals would call
Greenwich. The actual centre of Greenwich is between the Cutty Sark and
Greenwich DLR stations. But don't try changing from the Jubilee to DLR
at Canary Wharf because it's a long way to walk. It would be much better
to get an overground train to Greenwich (probably from Charing Cross,
walk from Embankment tube, having changed at Hammersmith).


Yeah, I was thinking the overground train would be better since it
brings you quickly to Greenwich (town), and also Maze Hill. Though
I think most of them leave from Cannon Street, through London Bridge.
So that would be the District Line from Hammersmith to Cannon Street.
If you go to London Bridge then you're probably taking the Jubilee Line
anyway, so you might as well stay on and take a 188 bus from
North Greenwich.

I expect the overground trains aren't as tourist friendly as the tube.

--
kedron

Knotso September 27th 03 05:21 AM

Hello from New York
 
Thanks all for correcting me. It was in fact the North Greenwich station.

It's looking like the Heathrow-Hammersmith-Westminster-North Greenwich option
is the best, since I'd like to avoid those 5-minute trudges up massive
stairwells.

thanks!

J


Roland Perry September 27th 03 07:18 AM

Hello from New York
 
In message , kedron
writes
I expect the overground trains aren't as tourist friendly as the tube.


The commuter trains (as they are) are equally tourist friendly.
--
Roland Perry

Cast_Iron September 27th 03 07:31 PM

Hello from New York
 

"Huge" wrote in message
...
(Knotso) writes:
Hi all and have patience with a newcomer.

I'm visiting London in a month -- for the first time -- and staying with

a
friend who lives in Greenwich. Pondering the tube map from Heathrow, it

appears
to be something like a 2-hour ride from the airport, to Green Park, to

the
Jubilee line to South Greenwich. But then, I have no benchmark to judge

how
long a ride it really is. Can anyone provide an estimate?


Get the Heathrow Express to Paddington.


And from there to Greenwich?



Paul Terry September 27th 03 08:26 PM

Hello from New York
 
In message , Huge
writes

(Knotso) writes:


I'm visiting London in a month -- for the first time -- and staying with a
friend who lives in Greenwich.


Get the Heathrow Express to Paddington.


How would that help him get to Greenwich?

--
Paul Terry

kedron September 27th 03 09:35 PM

Hello from New York
 

In
Roland Perry wrote:

I expect the overground trains aren't as tourist friendly as the tube.


The commuter trains (as they are) are equally tourist friendly.


Well, for a start, the trains aren't nearly as frequent, they have a different
ticketing system, and the route maps aren't as well publicised or as well-known
as the tube. For example, it wasn't at all clear where the journey in question
here starts from (mostly).

--
kedron

Nigel Pendse September 27th 03 10:21 PM

Hello from New York
 
"Huge" wrote in message

Paul Terry writes:

[20 lines snipped]

I seem to remember that the interchange at Green Park involves quite
a long underground walk


It does. And several flights of stairs.


The easier route is up the Piccadilly escalator to the booking hall and then
down the Victoria escalator. It's quicker and shorter. To minimise the
walking, board the last car of the Picc train and take the middle escalator.



Roland Perry September 28th 03 06:31 AM

Hello from New York
 
In message , kedron
writes

In
Roland Perry wrote:

I expect the overground trains aren't as tourist friendly as the tube.


The commuter trains (as they are) are equally tourist friendly.


Well, for a start, the trains aren't nearly as frequent,


Generally true, but does that matter very much for a tourist, rather
than someone-late-for-work? (Greenwich seems to have 6 tph to London,
although I accept that some are Cannon St, some Charing Cross. That's
more than many parts of the Metropolitan.)

they have a different ticketing system,


When did they stop taking travelcards?

and the route maps aren't as well publicised or as well-known as the
tube. For example, it wasn't at all clear where the journey in question
here starts from (mostly).


I was thinking more about the *trains* than the timetabling. eg Can you
get on and off them with luggage. Do the ones in that area stop at most
of the stations. And so on.
--
Roland Perry

Redonda September 28th 03 08:41 AM

Hello from New York
 
Martin S. wrote:
snip

Look at www.thetube.com and click on routefinder. It gives a rough
idea of journey times.
Regarding geographic tube maps, the best modern map of the central
area is at wwww.fourthway.co.uk - click on 'The Real Underground',
and
have a look through the options in the popup window.

HTH



You'd better knock off one of the 'w's for Fourthway (3 good, 4 bad)
or you get hijacked by yet another domain seller :-( When you *do*
get there the Shockwave animation is good :-)
--

Phil ,,,^.".^,,,


---
Outgoing mail is certified Virus Free.
Checked by AVG anti-virus system (http://www.grisoft.com).
Version: 6.0.521 / Virus Database: 319 - Release Date: 23/09/03



Wanderingjew698 September 28th 03 05:15 PM

Hello from New York
 
Sorry , if this sounds negative but I'm a londoner and I've ridden on many
metro systems (including the NYC subway many times) around the world and IMO
the tube is one of the worst run and managed I've ever come across plus its
the most expensive.

B2003







Are the LU Admonistrators named Moe Larry & Curly?NYUK NYUK

Paul Terry September 28th 03 07:32 PM

Hello from New York
 
In message , Huge
writes

Paul Terry writes:
In message , Huge
writes


I'm visiting London in a month -- for the first time -- and staying with a
friend who lives in Greenwich.


Get the Heathrow Express to Paddington.


How would that help him get to Greenwich?


Are you *really* this dim?


I have to ask you the same if you think that going via Paddington is a
better option. Did you really bother to check your figures?

The route I suggested takes 70-75 minutes, offers easy interchange for
visitors with luggage and costs under £10.

Your suggestion of using the Heathrow Express costs three times as much,
involves a difficult interchange at Paddington, plus another at Baker
Street, and is most unlikely to offer a shorter journey, especially
given the fact that one can have to wait up to 15 minutes for the HE at
Heathrow (as opposed to 5 minutes for the Piccadilly).

--
Paul Terry

Kilburn Kid September 29th 03 12:23 AM

Hello from New York
 


Well, it should be an eye-opener riding the London tube for the first time
after 3 years of living with New York subways. Anyone with experience commuting
on both transit systems who can venture opinions about the differences between
the two cities?

I've probably bothered you enough, but I welcome your opinions.

J


As a user of both systems, I would suggest the London network
certainly provides the best signposting whilst underground to direct
passengers at interchanges. Not a problem when you know when your
going but as a newcomer I found the lack of signs in New York time
consuming...

Kilburn Kid




Oliver Keating September 29th 03 06:35 PM

Hello from New York
 

"Boltar" wrote in message
m...
(Knotso) wrote in message

...
snip
The MTA in new york can actually manage to run a reasonable service. LU

can't.
In london there are forever delays , trains being reversed before they've
got to their destination because the train (ie driver) is running late

(wants
to get home for tea), stations being closed because of some lift or

escalator
not working, incorrect train arrival indicators and so on. Don't ever rely

on
the tube to get you to your destination on time and this especially

applies
when you're going to the airport on it.
Sorry , if this sounds negative but I'm a londoner and I've ridden on

many
metro systems (including the NYC subway many times) around the world and

IMO
the tube is one of the worst run and managed I've ever come across plus

its
the most expensive.


I am sorry but I disagree. I have ridden the tube every day, and I haven't
experienced a serious delay since three years ago when it took 45minutes to
travel 2 stops.

The problem is that a minority of dissatisfied customers will always speak
more loudly than the majority of satisfied ones, so come on speak up!

And besides the tube is only more expensive than other systems because tube
users actually pay for the real cost of the service. Which is how it should
be.

B2003



Sunny Dale September 29th 03 10:01 PM

Hello from New York
 
Best bet really is Heathrow Express into Paddington. Circle or Bakerloo to
Baker St and change for North Greenwich which will give u a seat on the tube
for that long stretch on the Jubilee.

Though if you want to see some of London in the air get a Bakerloo Line
train down to Charing Cross, take an overground train (South Eastern) get to
see the Thames for frequent trains to Greenwich.


"Knotso" wrote in message
...
Hi all and have patience with a newcomer.

I'm visiting London in a month -- for the first time -- and staying with a
friend who lives in Greenwich. Pondering the tube map from Heathrow, it

appears
to be something like a 2-hour ride from the airport, to Green Park, to the
Jubilee line to South Greenwich. But then, I have no benchmark to judge

how
long a ride it really is. Can anyone provide an estimate?

Being conditioned by New York subway maps, I have to admit the London

schematic
map drives me nuts. I can't get a true sense of direction of how close a
station is to a landmark. Which leads to my next question ... do any

geographic
maps of the tube exist? Where are they?

Well, it should be an eye-opener riding the London tube for the first time
after 3 years of living with New York subways. Anyone with experience

commuting
on both transit systems who can venture opinions about the differences

between
the two cities?

I've probably bothered you enough, but I welcome your opinions.

J



---
Outgoing mail is certified Virus Free.
Checked by AVG anti-virus system (
http://www.grisoft.com).
Version: 6.0.522 / Virus Database: 320 - Release Date: 29/09/2003



Wanderingjew698 September 30th 03 04:37 AM

Hello from New York
 

I am sorry but I disagree. I have ridden the tube every day, and I haven't
experienced a serious delay since three years ago when it took 45minutes to
travel 2 stops.

The problem is that a minority of dissatisfied customers will always speak
more loudly than the majority of satisfied ones, so come on speak up!

And besides the tube is only more expensive than other systems because tube
users actually pay for the real cost of the service. Which is how it should
be.

B2003









I beg to differ I was in London for 11days in june 2001 2 days the
Metropolitan Line was delayed with no trains between Aldgate and Baker
St from Baker St the trains were running at half the normal frequency.

Another day I sat for 45 minutes on the Picadilly Line between Covent Garden &
Leicester Sq because of a stalled train.

In NYC (where I live) I've been on locals who have been rerouted on the express
tracks and vice versa causing maybe 5 or 10 minute delays

I believe except for London which has parallel trackage from Barons Court to
Acton Town and from Finchley Road to Wembley Park and Chicago from Howard to
Fullerton and Philadelphia Broad St Line from Olney to Spring Garden NYC has
extensive parrallel trackage

Clive D. W. Feather September 30th 03 09:00 AM

Hello from New York
 
In article , Paul Terry
writes
I seem to remember that the interchange at Green Park involves quite a
long underground walk


It's a corridor that takes me (as a fairly fit person) two or three
minutes to walk. At each end you have a choice of stairs or a lift
(elevator to the original poster).

--
Clive D.W. Feather, writing for himself | Home:
Tel: +44 20 8371 1138 (work) | Web: http://www.davros.org
Fax: +44 870 051 9937 | Work:
Written on my laptop; please observe the Reply-To address

Clive D. W. Feather September 30th 03 09:00 AM

Hello from New York
 
In article ,
Wanderingjew698 writes
I believe except for London which has parallel trackage from Barons Court to
Acton Town and from Finchley Road to Wembley Park


to Moor Park, actually.

--
Clive D.W. Feather, writing for himself | Home:
Tel: +44 20 8371 1138 (work) | Web: http://www.davros.org
Fax: +44 870 051 9937 | Work:
Written on my laptop; please observe the Reply-To address

Boltar September 30th 03 12:14 PM

Hello from New York
 
"Oliver Keating" wrote in message ...
I am sorry but I disagree. I have ridden the tube every day, and I haven't
experienced a serious delay since three years ago when it took 45minutes to
travel 2 stops.

The problem is that a minority of dissatisfied customers will always speak
more loudly than the majority of satisfied ones, so come on speak up!


Well then you've been lucky mate, I get delayed by more than 20 mins at least
once a week. Still , on the bright side at least I'm building up a nice
collection of refund vouchers.


And besides the tube is only more expensive than other systems because tube
users actually pay for the real cost of the service. Which is how it should
be.


WHy should I have to pay so much for a PUBLIC service that allows me travel
to work so that i can earn money to PAY TAXES THAT FUND IT!?? Using your logic
we'd all have to pay £££ just to visit the doctor. Ok , not everything can
be funded by taxes but public services should be IMO and that includes the
tube. Since virtualy every other country does that (with some minimum fare
to keep out vagrants and top up the coffers) I suspect we are the ones who
need a rethink , not the rest of the world.

B2003

Spyke September 30th 03 12:55 PM

Hello from New York
 
In message ,
Wanderingjew698 writes

I am sorry but I disagree. I have ridden the tube every day, and I haven't
experienced a serious delay since three years ago when it took 45minutes to
travel 2 stops.

The problem is that a minority of dissatisfied customers will always speak
more loudly than the majority of satisfied ones, so come on speak up!

And besides the tube is only more expensive than other systems because tube
users actually pay for the real cost of the service. Which is how it should
be.

B2003









I beg to differ I was in London for 11days in june 2001 2 days the
Metropolitan Line was delayed with no trains between Aldgate and Baker
St from Baker St the trains were running at half the normal frequency.

Another day I sat for 45 minutes on the Picadilly Line between Covent Garden &
Leicester Sq because of a stalled train.

In NYC (where I live) I've been on locals who have been rerouted on the express
tracks and vice versa causing maybe 5 or 10 minute delays

I believe except for London which has parallel trackage from Barons Court to
Acton Town and from Finchley Road to Wembley Park


There is also plenty of parallel track on the Met line north of Wembley
Park, allowing a mixture of Fast and All-Stations services.
In normal practice, the Finchley Rd - Wembley Park section is treated as
two separate lines, Jubilee on the inner tracks, Met on the outer.
--
Spyke
Address is valid, but messages are treated as junk. The opinions I express do
not necessarily reflect those of the educational institution from which I post.

Wanderingjew698 September 30th 03 05:13 PM

Hello from New York
 
In normal practice, the Finchley Rd - Wembley Park section is treated as
two separate lines, Jubilee on the inner tracks, Met on the outer.


Can they reroute the Met on the Jubilee in case of breakdowns?

Spyke September 30th 03 07:21 PM

Hello from New York
 
In message ,
Wanderingjew698 writes
In normal practice, the Finchley Rd - Wembley Park section is treated as
two separate lines, Jubilee on the inner tracks, Met on the outer.


Can they reroute the Met on the Jubilee in case of breakdowns?


Quail shows a connections at Neasden and Finchley Rd between the two
lines, but looks like Met to Jubilee is easier than vice-versa. I
presume the jubilee lines are able to accommodate the Met loading gauge?
--
Spyke
Address is valid, but messages are treated as junk. The opinions I express do
not necessarily reflect those of the educational institution from which I post.

Cast_Iron September 30th 03 08:55 PM

Hello from New York
 
Spyke wrote:
In message ,
Wanderingjew698 writes
In normal practice, the Finchley Rd - Wembley Park
section is treated as two separate lines, Jubilee on the
inner tracks, Met on the outer.


Can they reroute the Met on the Jubilee in case of
breakdowns?


Quail shows a connections at Neasden and Finchley Rd
between the two lines, but looks like Met to Jubilee is
easier than vice-versa. I
presume the jubilee lines are able to accommodate the Met
loading gauge?


Certainly not south of Finchley Road.



Clive D. W. Feather October 1st 03 09:11 AM

Hello from New York
 
In article , Spyke
writes
Quail shows a connections at Neasden and Finchley Rd between the two
lines, but looks like Met to Jubilee is easier than vice-versa. I
presume the jubilee lines are able to accommodate the Met loading gauge?


Yes; it used to be that the last Met. train ran along the Jubilee tracks
and called at all stations.

However, I believe that preparations for ATO on the Jubilee means that A
stock is no longer allowed on it.

--
Clive D.W. Feather, writing for himself | Home:
Tel: +44 20 8371 1138 (work) | Web: http://www.davros.org
Fax: +44 870 051 9937 | Work:
Written on my laptop; please observe the Reply-To address

Nicholas F Hodder October 2nd 03 06:35 AM

Hello from New York
 
"Knotso" wrote in message
...
Hi all and have patience with a newcomer.

Being conditioned by New York subway maps, I have to admit the London

schematic
map drives me nuts. I can't get a true sense of direction of how close a
station is to a landmark. Which leads to my next question ... do any

geographic
maps of the tube exist? Where are they?


There's a very good geographical map at:

http://www.kordy.dircon.co.uk/misc/lul.gif

I found this from a link on the following page:

http://owen.massey.net/tubemaps.html




All times are GMT. The time now is 11:50 AM.

Powered by vBulletin®
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004-2006 LondonBanter.co.uk