London Banter

London Banter (https://www.londonbanter.co.uk/forum.php)
-   London Transport (https://www.londonbanter.co.uk/london-transport/)
-   -   New Victoria Line Stock (https://www.londonbanter.co.uk/london-transport/11021-new-victoria-line-stock.html)

Phil Richards July 27th 10 06:24 PM

New Victoria Line Stock
 
http://www.thisislondon.co.uk/standa...n-the-old-ones.

I have to say breakdowns over the last week or so seem to be more common...

--
Phil Richards, London, UK
3,600+ railway photos since 1980 at:
http://europeanrail.fotopic.net
http://britishrail.fotopic.net

Phil Richards July 27th 10 06:28 PM

New Victoria Line Stock
 
Phil Richards wrote:
http://www.thisislondon.co.uk/standa...n-the-old-ones.


I have to say breakdowns over the last week or so seem to be more common...


This link might work better:

http://tiny.cc/uhvxk


--
Phil Richards, London, UK
3,600+ railway photos since 1980 at:
http://europeanrail.fotopic.net
http://britishrail.fotopic.net

Tom Anderson July 27th 10 09:01 PM

New Victoria Line Stock
 
On Tue, 27 Jul 2010, Phil Richards wrote:

Phil Richards wrote:
http://www.thisislondon.co.uk/standa...n-the-old-ones.

I have to say breakdowns over the last week or so seem to be more common...


This link might work better:

http://tiny.cc/uhvxk


As might this:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bathtub_curve

:)

tom

--
Any Christmas message which ends with "... everything's pointless
...." probably doesn't need sharing -- cleanskies

Nicola Redwood July 27th 10 09:30 PM

New Victoria Line Stock
 
Have been on them twice so far and both times the trains were taken out of
service due to problems

I've avoided getting on them as well, but that's because they give such an
uncomfortable and frankly disconcerting ride

Fortunately due to the astoundingly bright light on the front, they can be
detected before getting close to the platform

After 2 weeks of appalling service on the normally fairly reliable Victoria
Line, I finally saw an apology at Blackhorse Road tonight. In the last 10
days, I've been very late for work after a much unwanted sauna on 4
occasions

My best alternative route involves the Jubilee Line which I am aware is not
too reliable. It seems even the DLR cannot be relied upon these days

I would like to add I have no complaints when it comes to staff or customer
service and even onboard communication has generally been good. Could have
been better at Liverpool St on Monday morning with severe overcrowding.
There was a moment when I genuinely feared for my life




[email protected] July 27th 10 10:04 PM

New Victoria Line Stock
 
On 27/07/2010 22:30, Nicola Redwood wrote:
Have been on them twice so far and both times the trains were taken out of
service due to problems

I've avoided getting on them as well, but that's because they give such an
uncomfortable and frankly disconcerting ride

Fortunately due to the astoundingly bright light on the front, they can be
detected before getting close to the platform

After 2 weeks of appalling service on the normally fairly reliable Victoria
Line, I finally saw an apology at Blackhorse Road tonight. In the last 10
days, I've been very late for work after a much unwanted sauna on 4
occasions

My best alternative route involves the Jubilee Line which I am aware is not
too reliable. It seems even the DLR cannot be relied upon these days

I would like to add I have no complaints when it comes to staff or customer
service and even onboard communication has generally been good. Could have
been better at Liverpool St on Monday morning with severe overcrowding.
There was a moment when I genuinely feared for my life



At least you got to see one.

Nicola Redwood July 27th 10 11:53 PM

New Victoria Line Stock
 

At least you got to see one.


Have seen them a few times at Kings X Northbound between 6pm and 6:30pm
weekdays



[email protected] July 28th 10 08:27 AM

New Victoria Line Stock
 
On Tue, 27 Jul 2010 22:30:53 +0100
"Nicola Redwood" wrote:
Have been on them twice so far and both times the trains were taken out of
service due to problems


Apparently some of the problems have been down to door sensors. It just
beggers belief that in 2010 they still can't design door sensors that can
cope with an overcrowded tube train. This really should be simple basic
engineering that an undergraduate could design.

B2003



MIG July 28th 10 09:29 AM

New Victoria Line Stock
 
On 28 July, 09:27, wrote:
On Tue, 27 Jul 2010 22:30:53 +0100

"Nicola Redwood" wrote:
Have been on them twice so far and both times the trains were taken out of
service due to problems


Apparently some of the problems have been down to door sensors. It just
beggers belief that in 2010 they still can't design door sensors that can
cope with an overcrowded tube train. This really should be simple basic
engineering that an undergraduate could design.

B2003


So should designing a seat that fits a human being. So should putting
windows in train sides.

I think that 2009 stock seats should be compulsory at TfL board
meetings from now on.

[email protected] July 28th 10 10:38 AM

New Victoria Line Stock
 
On Wed, 28 Jul 2010 02:29:38 -0700 (PDT)
MIG wrote:
So should designing a seat that fits a human being. So should putting
windows in train sides.


They're not as bad as the C stock seats though. Whoever decided the width
of those was either a sadist or good friends with Snow White.

I think that 2009 stock seats should be compulsory at TfL board
meetings from now on.


Now theres an idea :)

B2003


Railist[_2_] July 28th 10 11:47 AM

New Victoria Line Stock
 
On 28 July, 10:29, MIG wrote:
On 28 July, 09:27, wrote:

On Tue, 27 Jul 2010 22:30:53 +0100


"Nicola Redwood" wrote:
Have been on them twice so far and both times the trains were taken out of
service due to problems


Apparently some of the problems have been down to door sensors. It just
beggers belief that in 2010 they still can't design door sensors that can
cope with an overcrowded tube train. This really should be simple basic
engineering that an undergraduate could design.


B2003


So should designing a seat that fits a human being. *So should putting
windows in train sides.

I think that 2009 stock seats should be compulsory at TfL board
meetings from now on.


I don't have a problem with seats normally - they do feel narrow on
the Piccadilly Line but that's probably my imagination... ;-) I was on
a new Victoria Line train yesterday and it was extremely hot - the
hottest I have ever been on a tube journey and not in a good way. It
felt like the heating was on, the train was packed and it crawled
between stations.

Paul July 28th 10 12:30 PM

New Victoria Line Stock
 
On 28 July, 12:47, Railist wrote:
On 28 July, 10:29, MIG wrote:





On 28 July, 09:27, wrote:


On Tue, 27 Jul 2010 22:30:53 +0100


"Nicola Redwood" wrote:
Have been on them twice so far and both times the trains were taken out of
service due to problems


Apparently some of the problems have been down to door sensors. It just
beggers belief that in 2010 they still can't design door sensors that can
cope with an overcrowded tube train. This really should be simple basic
engineering that an undergraduate could design.


B2003


So should designing a seat that fits a human being. *So should putting
windows in train sides.


I think that 2009 stock seats should be compulsory at TfL board
meetings from now on.


I don't have a problem with seats normally - they do feel narrow on
the Piccadilly Line but that's probably my imagination... ;-) I was on
a new Victoria Line train yesterday and it was extremely hot - the
hottest I have ever been on a tube journey and not in a good way. It
felt like the heating was on, the train was packed and it crawled
between stations.- Hide quoted text -

- Show quoted text -


I was on the Northbound Victoria line platform at Kings Cross
yesterday at about 4pm, when a new train pulled in. There was an
anonuncement "...this train is being taken out of service, please do
not board this train....", and everyone got off. Since we were not
given an explanation as to why the train was taken out of service
(when does that ever happen?) it may be the case that there was a
defect with the train, There was also a notice at Kings Cross the
other day apologising for the service on the Victoria line over the
past couple of weeks. (eg. service suspended between Walthamstow and
Seven Sisters on Monday 19th due to "..late finish of overnight
engineering work...)

MIG July 28th 10 01:07 PM

New Victoria Line Stock
 
On 28 July, 12:47, Railist wrote:
On 28 July, 10:29, MIG wrote:





On 28 July, 09:27, wrote:


On Tue, 27 Jul 2010 22:30:53 +0100


"Nicola Redwood" wrote:
Have been on them twice so far and both times the trains were taken out of
service due to problems


Apparently some of the problems have been down to door sensors. It just
beggers belief that in 2010 they still can't design door sensors that can
cope with an overcrowded tube train. This really should be simple basic
engineering that an undergraduate could design.


B2003


So should designing a seat that fits a human being. *So should putting
windows in train sides.


I think that 2009 stock seats should be compulsory at TfL board
meetings from now on.


I don't have a problem with seats normally - they do feel narrow on
the Piccadilly Line but that's probably my imagination... ;-) I was on
a new Victoria Line train yesterday and it was extremely hot - the
hottest I have ever been on a tube journey and not in a good way. It
felt like the heating was on, the train was packed and it crawled
between stations.- Hide quoted text -

- Show quoted text -


Even on the Piccadilly, where I don't like the refurbished seating
arrangement, I can put my bum at the back of the seat and lean back.

I can't do that in 2009 stock; I would be forced to lean forward. If
I slump forwards and lean back, my back is then supported only by the
hard ridge at the top of the seat.

Extremely unpleasant either way.

Fat richard July 28th 10 06:15 PM

New Victoria Line Stock
 
On 28 July, 10:29, MIG wrote:
On 28 July, 09:27, wrote:

On Tue, 27 Jul 2010 22:30:53 +0100


"Nicola Redwood" wrote:
Have been on them twice so far and both times the trains were taken out of
service due to problems


Apparently some of the problems have been down to door sensors. It just
beggers belief that in 2010 they still can't design door sensors that can
cope with an overcrowded tube train. This really should be simple basic
engineering that an undergraduate could design.


B2003


So should designing a seat that fits a human being. *So should putting
windows in train sides.

I think that 2009 stock seats should be compulsory at TfL board
meetings from now on.



Going are the days of those lovely transverse pairs in the driving
cars......................
At least the Bakerloo stock will be around a while.


I will have to stand in futre (the excercise does me good). When I say
I will have to stand, I actually mean that......


Fat Richard

[email protected] July 28th 10 08:13 PM

New Victoria Line Stock
 
On 28/07/2010 19:45, Paul Corfield wrote:
On Tue, 27 Jul 2010 23:04:07 +0100, "
wrote:
[09 stock]

At least you got to see one.


I keep reading comments like this on blogs and find it rather odd given
there are 7 or 8 of the things knocking around M-F. I can't avoid them
now in the mornings. Trains 234 (0658), 235 (0703), 236 (0708) and 237
(0712) ex Seven Sisters s/b are now all 09 stock. It's almost as if the
Vic Line management has calibrated their "Corfield radar" to align with
the despatch of new trains from Northumberland Park depot.

Trains running through from Walthamstow at that time of day are 67 stock
but are so full you can't get a seat at Seven Sisters.

I regularly see 09 stock in the evenings too.

None of them are running at the weekends, are they?

[email protected] July 28th 10 09:07 PM

New Victoria Line Stock
 
On 28/07/2010 19:45, Paul Corfield wrote:
On Tue, 27 Jul 2010 23:04:07 +0100, "
wrote:
[09 stock]

At least you got to see one.


I keep reading comments like this on blogs and find it rather odd given
there are 7 or 8 of the things knocking around M-F. I can't avoid them
now in the mornings. Trains 234 (0658), 235 (0703), 236 (0708) and 237
(0712) ex Seven Sisters s/b are now all 09 stock. It's almost as if the
Vic Line management has calibrated their "Corfield radar" to align with
the despatch of new trains from Northumberland Park depot.

Trains running through from Walthamstow at that time of day are 67 stock
but are so full you can't get a seat at Seven Sisters.

I regularly see 09 stock in the evenings too.


The 09 stock kind of strikes me as an urban legend. Somebody who knows
somebody who knows somebody once claimed to have seen one.




MIG July 28th 10 09:42 PM

New Victoria Line Stock
 
On 28 July, 22:07, "
wrote:
On 28/07/2010 19:45, Paul Corfield wrote:





On Tue, 27 Jul 2010 23:04:07 +0100, "
*wrote:
[09 stock]


At least you got to see one.


I keep reading comments like this on blogs and find it rather odd given
there are 7 or 8 of the things knocking around M-F. I can't avoid them
now in the mornings. Trains 234 (0658), 235 (0703), 236 (0708) and 237
(0712) ex Seven Sisters s/b are now all 09 stock. It's almost as if the
Vic Line management has calibrated their "Corfield radar" to align with
the despatch of new trains from Northumberland Park depot.


Trains running through from Walthamstow at that time of day are 67 stock
but are so full you can't get a seat at Seven Sisters.


I regularly see 09 stock in the evenings too.


The 09 stock kind of strikes me as an urban legend. Somebody who knows
somebody who knows somebody once claimed to have seen one.



If only. Unfortunately, I have experienced them myself.

[email protected] July 29th 10 08:41 AM

New Victoria Line Stock
 
On Wed, 28 Jul 2010 11:15:31 -0700 (PDT)
Fat richard wrote:
Going are the days of those lovely transverse pairs in the driving
cars......................


I never found the tranverse seating as comfy as other people. The seats
are too narrow for 2 people to sit on them confortably so you either end up
squashed against the wall as the person next to you tries to get as much
space as possible or sitting with a third of your bum dangling off the edge of
the seat and getting knocked as people move along the aisle at every stop.
Tube trains are just too narrow for that kind of seating though I don't
see why they couldn't have continued with it on the sub surface stock.

I will have to stand in futre (the excercise does me good). When I say
I will have to stand, I actually mean that......


I think it was a serious suggestion at one time - a tube train with no
seats.

B2003


Recliner[_2_] July 29th 10 10:26 AM

New Victoria Line Stock
 
wrote in message

On Wed, 28 Jul 2010 11:15:31 -0700 (PDT)
Fat richard wrote:
Going are the days of those lovely transverse pairs in the driving
cars......................


I never found the tranverse seating as comfy as other people. The
seats
are too narrow for 2 people to sit on them confortably so you either
end up squashed against the wall as the person next to you tries to
get as much space as possible or sitting with a third of your bum
dangling off the edge of the seat and getting knocked as people move
along the aisle at every stop. Tube trains are just too narrow for
that kind of seating though I don't
see why they couldn't have continued with it on the sub surface stock.


I wonder why Tube stock don't use 2+1 transverse seating? This would
give adequately wide seats and a wide aisle, so it should be popular
with passengers. Yes, it would reduce seating capacity, but in a nicer
way than the all longitudinal arrangement. The new Met S Stock also
features a variant of this idea.



Paul July 29th 10 10:33 AM

New Victoria Line Stock
 
On 29 July, 11:26, "Recliner" wrote:
wrote in message



On Wed, 28 Jul 2010 11:15:31 -0700 (PDT)
Fat richard wrote:
Going are the days of those lovely transverse pairs in the driving
cars......................


I never found the tranverse seating as comfy as other people. The
seats
are too narrow for 2 people to sit on them confortably so you either
end up squashed against the wall as the person next to you tries to
get as much space as possible or sitting with a third of your bum
dangling off the edge of the seat and getting knocked as people move
along the aisle at every stop. Tube trains are just too narrow for
that kind of seating though I don't
see why they couldn't have continued with it on the sub surface stock.


I wonder why Tube stock don't use 2+1 transverse seating? *This would
give adequately wide seats and a wide aisle, so it should be popular
with passengers. Yes, it would reduce seating capacity, but in a nicer
way than the all longitudinal arrangement. *The new Met S Stock also
features a variant of this idea.


And now LUL have admitted that there are problems with the new trains
on the Victoria Line.

From the BBC News website

New trains on the Victoria Line on London Underground (LU) have been
hit by technical problems, Transport for London (TfL) has admitted.
The latest disruption on Monday saw a new train break down for 60
minutes during the morning rush hour at Oxford Circus.
On 21 July, about 3,000 passengers were trapped when another train
broke down.
TfL said there would be better journeys once the line moved to new
signalling equipment and tracks by 2012.
The new fleet of trains, part of a £90m upgrade of the Victoria Line,
began operating from July 2009.


TfL promised passengers a "smoother, more comfortable ride, with more
frequent trains, a reduction in journey times" and more capacity.
But the problems have been caused by computer software failures and
from over-sensitive sensors, which stop the trains when passengers
lean against doors.
The new trains have in-carriage CCTV, improved wheelchair access,
better ventilation and improved visual and audio customer information
systems.
At the time of their launch, Richard Parry, LU's managing director,
said the trains had "undergone hundreds of hours of testing and are
now ready to run".
On the latest disruptions, a TfL spokesperson said: "The Victoria Line
was suspended for around an hour on Monday morning due to a faulty
train at Oxford Circus station.
"The Victoria Line is undergoing a complete renewal and this includes
the introduction of new trains.
"There have been some technical issues with the new trains but we are
working hard to rectify these initial faults.
"Once the upgrade is finished in 2012 the new track and signalling
will mean faster, smoother and more reliable journeys for our
customers."
On the technical problems, she added: "During any changeover to new
trains and/or signalling systems, the reliability will be expected to
grow over time."
Connor Kinnear, who founded a website just over a month ago which
helps people claim for journeys on the Tube if they are delayed, said:
"We have seen a huge rise, especially this week, both in the number of
refund claims made against the Victoria Line and also the number of
new users registering to the site."



MIG July 29th 10 11:36 AM

New Victoria Line Stock
 
On 29 July, 09:41, wrote:
On Wed, 28 Jul 2010 11:15:31 -0700 (PDT)

Fat richard wrote:
Going are the days of those lovely transverse pairs in the driving
cars......................


I never found the tranverse seating as comfy as other people. The seats
are too narrow for 2 people to sit on them confortably so you either end up
squashed against the wall as the person next to you tries to get as much
space as possible or sitting with a third of your bum dangling off the edge of
the seat and getting knocked as people move along the aisle at every stop.
Tube trains are just too narrow for that kind of seating though I don't
see why they couldn't have continued with it on the sub surface stock.

I will have to stand in futre (the excercise does me good). When I say
I will have to stand, I actually mean that......


I think it was a serious suggestion at one time - a tube train with no
seats.

B2003


The way things are going, with walls thickening and obstructions
getting more chunky, by the time that the 2009 stock is replaced, it
will be by carriages which are nearly-solid rods with a small pipe
down the middle that a person can crawl into, with personal space
divided into person lengths by means of spikes every four feet along.

[email protected] July 29th 10 12:00 PM

New Victoria Line Stock
 
On Thu, 29 Jul 2010 03:33:42 -0700 (PDT)
Paul wrote:
But the problems have been caused by computer software failures and


No doubt as usual there'll be software for the sake of it where its not
needed for trivially simple operations such as door closing and ventilation
fans. All of which has to be debugged.

At the time of their launch, Richard Parry, LU's managing director,
said the trains had "undergone hundreds of hours of testing and are
now ready to run".


Testing without a fully loaded train of people isn't testing.

B2003



[email protected] July 29th 10 12:01 PM

New Victoria Line Stock
 
On Thu, 29 Jul 2010 04:36:20 -0700 (PDT)
MIG wrote:
The way things are going, with walls thickening and obstructions
getting more chunky, by the time that the 2009 stock is replaced, it
will be by carriages which are nearly-solid rods with a small pipe
down the middle that a person can crawl into, with personal space
divided into person lengths by means of spikes every four feet along.


Sshh, don't give them ideas!

B2003


Steve Dulieu July 29th 10 04:53 PM

New Victoria Line Stock
 

"Railist" wrote in message
...
On 28 July, 10:29, MIG wrote:
On 28 July, 09:27, wrote:

On Tue, 27 Jul 2010 22:30:53 +0100


I don't have a problem with seats normally - they do feel narrow on
the Piccadilly Line but that's probably my imagination... ;-)

Ah, you need to use the old "left of the door gag". Those of us Picc line
users who are perhaps best described as "circumferencally challenged" know
that the seat immediately to the left of each door is slightly wider than
the rest of the seats in the car. To see what I mean, try to get on an empty
(ish) car and sit in the seat to the left of the door you entered by, then
try the seat directly opposite. The seat you sat in first is wider.
--
Cheers, Steve.
Change jealous to sad to reply.


Paul July 30th 10 06:52 AM

New Victoria Line Stock
 
On 29 July, 19:07, Paul Corfield wrote:
On Wed, 28 Jul 2010 22:07:28 +0100, "

wrote:
The 09 stock kind of strikes me as an urban legend. Somebody who knows
somebody who knows somebody once claimed to have seen one.


Well if that's how you wish to consider them fine. *I assume you
therefore consider all the other reams of remarks from various posters
on here, endless newspaper and web comments over the last few days to be
completely fallacious just because you personally have not been on one
of these trains!? *I shall also assume the one I caught to work this
morning and the one in the platform at Victoria this afternoon were also
figments of my imagination. *Can't wait to tell everyone that I was
really teleported by the power of my imagination to work most mornings
this week!

Do you think the world isn't round because you haven't personally been
in orbit or else flown round the world?
--
Paul C


I got on one of these "figments of my imagination" to go home last
night, and the train was quite sticky and hot inside. This was
probably due to the fact that the ventilators were blowing warm air
around the carriage. Perhaps LUL could advertise that the new
Victoria Line trains come with free hair dryers! I assume that they
will wait until the middle of winter before they make them blow cold
air.

Joking apart, I should have thought that these issues would have been
detected and fixed during the "extensive hours of testing" that were
carried out last year. (and for which we had to endure a series of
weekend closures last summer)

[email protected] July 31st 10 04:24 PM

New Victoria Line Stock
 
On 28/07/2010 19:15, Fat richard wrote:
On 28 July, 10:29, wrote:
On 28 July, 09:27, wrote:

On Tue, 27 Jul 2010 22:30:53 +0100


"Nicola wrote:
Have been on them twice so far and both times the trains were taken out of
service due to problems


Apparently some of the problems have been down to door sensors. It just
beggers belief that in 2010 they still can't design door sensors that can
cope with an overcrowded tube train. This really should be simple basic
engineering that an undergraduate could design.


B2003


So should designing a seat that fits a human being. So should putting
windows in train sides.

I think that 2009 stock seats should be compulsory at TfL board
meetings from now on.



Going are the days of those lovely transverse pairs in the driving
cars......................
At least the Bakerloo stock will be around a while.


I will have to stand in futre (the excercise does me good). When I say
I will have to stand, I actually mean that......


Fat Richard


Finally got to see one today. It was interesting how bright the
headlights were. The seats were definitely different from the ones on
the 67 stock, but I wonder if that is not meant in some way to keep
passengers from nodding off.



Nicola Redwood August 5th 10 09:08 PM

New Victoria Line Stock
 

"Nicola Redwood" wrote in message
...

At least you got to see one.


Have seen them a few times at Kings X Northbound between 6pm and 6:30pm
weekdays

In the past 24 hours, I've been on two and seen 2 more




All times are GMT. The time now is 11:38 AM.

Powered by vBulletin®
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004-2006 LondonBanter.co.uk