Given the that the increased road congestion in Friday and Sunday evenings
is caused by many people going and from to their country cottages for the
weekend, isn't it time that second homes attracted a punative rate of
council tax?

An added bonus of this would be to free-up houses in rural and other
touristy areas that young people on local wages could afford to buy or rent
who would then spend money in the local economy.

Cast_Iron wrote:
Given the that the increased road congestion in Friday and Sunday
evenings is caused by many people going and from to their country
cottages for the weekend, isn't it time that second homes attracted a
punative rate of council tax?

Is it not mostly caused by either:

(a) people who work in the South-East during the week travelling home for
the weekend, or

(b) people visiting friends and relatives for the weekend

--
http://www.speedlimit.org.uk
"Necessity is the plea for every infringement of human freedom.
It is the argument of tyrants; it is the creed of slaves." (William
Pitt, 1783)

"Cast_Iron" wrote in message
...
Given the that the increased road congestion in Friday and Sunday
evenings
is caused by many people going and from to their country cottages for the
weekend, isn't it time that second homes attracted a punative rate of
council tax?

An added bonus of this would be to free-up houses in rural and other
touristy areas that young people on local wages could afford to buy or
rent
who would then spend money in the local economy.



I can't say I have a second home, but why should a second home be heavily
taxed? Second homes make very low demands upon local services. I would
suspect that even if you prevented anyone from owning a second home, it
would make little difference to the general housing market.

People travelling to their 2nd homes pay plenty of tax travelling to them. I
would suspect most traffic though is caused by people seeing friends or
relatives, or travelling to/from their place of work for the week.

Mikael

"Cast_Iron" wrote in message
...
Given the that the increased road congestion in Friday and Sunday
evenings
is caused by many people going and from to their country cottages for the
weekend, isn't it time that second homes attracted a punative rate of
council tax?

An added bonus of this would be to free-up houses in rural and other
touristy areas that young people on local wages could afford to buy or
rent
who would then spend money in the local economy.



Absouletely. Anyone with a second home should be made to absolutely pay
through-the-nose for it.

"Mikael Armstrong" wrote in message
...
"Cast_Iron" wrote in message
...
Given the that the increased road congestion in Friday and Sunday
evenings
is caused by many people going and from to their country cottages for
the
weekend, isn't it time that second homes attracted a punative rate of
council tax?

An added bonus of this would be to free-up houses in rural and other
touristy areas that young people on local wages could afford to buy or
rent
who would then spend money in the local economy.



I can't say I have a second home, but why should a second home be heavily
taxed?

Because people who own 2 houses are clearly very rich, and the rich should
be targeted for tax for two reasons:

1) Social justice
2) It would actually be impossible to raise enough revenue if everyone was
taxed to the same %age because the rich provide a disproportionately large
chunk of revenue.

Second homes make very low demands upon local services. I would
suspect that even if you prevented anyone from owning a second home, it
would make little difference to the general housing market.

This is completely untrue. There are many examples in West England where the
popularity of second homes, particularly in scenic locations, has driven up
prices making it really hard for people with local jobs to find somewhere
affordable.

People travelling to their 2nd homes pay plenty of tax travelling to them.
I
would suspect most traffic though is caused by people seeing friends or
relatives, or travelling to/from their place of work for the week.

The thing is, most people with a 2nd home will travel there every weekend
without fail.

Mikael

"Cast_Iron" wrote in message
...
Given the that the increased road congestion in Friday and Sunday
evenings
is caused by many people going and from to their country cottages for the
weekend, isn't it time that second homes attracted a punative rate of
council tax?

No.

An added bonus of this would be to free-up houses in rural and other
touristy areas that young people on local wages could afford to buy or
rent
who would then spend money in the local economy.

If you have to rent or buy, you have to rent or buy - it's that simple.

--
The DervMan
www.dervman.com

"Oliver Keating" wrote in message
...

"Mikael Armstrong" wrote in message
...
"Cast_Iron" wrote in message
...
Given the that the increased road congestion in Friday and Sunday
evenings
is caused by many people going and from to their country cottages for
the
weekend, isn't it time that second homes attracted a punative rate of
council tax?

An added bonus of this would be to free-up houses in rural and other
touristy areas that young people on local wages could afford to buy or
rent
who would then spend money in the local economy.



I can't say I have a second home, but why should a second home be
heavily
taxed?

Because people who own 2 houses are clearly very rich, and the rich should
be targeted for tax for two reasons:

1) Social justice
2) It would actually be impossible to raise enough revenue if everyone was
taxed to the same %age because the rich provide a disproportionately large
chunk of revenue.

Second homes make very low demands upon local services. I would
suspect that even if you prevented anyone from owning a second home, it
would make little difference to the general housing market.

This is completely untrue. There are many examples in West England where
the
popularity of second homes, particularly in scenic locations, has driven
up
prices making it really hard for people with local jobs to find somewhere
affordable.

It is the lack of supply which will have driven prices up. Lets face it, out
of teh total population, very few people have 2nd homes, so you would not
have to let many new homes to be built to offset the effect in the areas
concerned. Lets allow people to build a few more houses in the areas people
actually want to live in, rather than proposing more construction in the
areas already filled to the brim.

People travelling to their 2nd homes pay plenty of tax travelling to
them.
I
would suspect most traffic though is caused by people seeing friends or
relatives, or travelling to/from their place of work for the week.

The thing is, most people with a 2nd home will travel there every weekend
without fail.

And so what? They already pay the petrol tax, they will have paid stamp duty
buying the house (another unfair tax), and no doubt they will be high
earners paying fair amounts of income tax too.

Many people owning 2nd homes probably also spend a reasonable amount in the
local area where they travel to at the weekends, and perhaps will have
employed local people to renovate the houses if needed. Wealth and properity
comes from people doing business, not from taxes.


Mikael

PeterE wrote...

Cast_Iron wrote:

Given the that the increased road congestion in Friday and Sunday
evenings is caused by many people going and from to their country
cottages for the weekend, isn't it time that second homes attracted a
punative rate of council tax?

Is it not mostly caused by either:
(a) people who work in the South-East during the week travelling home for
the weekend, or
(b) people visiting friends and relatives for the weekend

Don't feed the trolls.

"Oliver Keating" wrote in message
...

"Cast_Iron" wrote in message
...
Given the that the increased road congestion in Friday and Sunday
evenings
is caused by many people going and from to their country cottages for
the
weekend, isn't it time that second homes attracted a punative rate of
council tax?

An added bonus of this would be to free-up houses in rural and other
touristy areas that young people on local wages could afford to buy or
rent
who would then spend money in the local economy.



Absouletely. Anyone with a second home should be made to absolutely pay
through-the-nose for it.



Are you suggesting then that people who buy a small flat near their place of
work and have a house in the suburbs or countryside where the rest of their
family live should be penalised for it? Surely you would advocate people
living close to where they work and reducing their reliance upon the
transport infrastructure? Taxes like everything work both ways.

Mikael

"DervMan" wrote in message
...
"Cast_Iron" wrote in message
...
Given the that the increased road congestion in Friday and Sunday
evenings
is caused by many people going and from to their country cottages for
the
weekend, isn't it time that second homes attracted a punative rate of
council tax?

No.

An added bonus of this would be to free-up houses in rural and other
touristy areas that young people on local wages could afford to buy or
rent
who would then spend money in the local economy.

If you have to rent or buy, you have to rent or buy - it's that simple.


But it is the question of affordability in relation to local wages that is
the cause for concern.